Planning to haul gear for your next adventure but tired of overflowing cargo space? You’re not alone! Roof racks are definitely an unbeatable solution, but the choice between a cargo basket and a cargo box can put you in a fix. However, the right rooftop copyright is no less than a game-changer in the next getaway you set off for. 

While both cargo baskets and cargo boxes are excellent ways to transport gear securely and efficiently, they have their own distinct USPs that set them apart from each other. We have put together this guide to help you weigh the pros and cons of both, and accordingly decide which option best suits your needs. 

Ready to transform your vehicle into a true adventure mobile?

Cargo Baskets: A Closer Look

The most common form of rooftop cargo-carrying contraption, cargo baskets are very easily available, be it at sporting goods stores, auto parts outlets, or vehicle outfitters. When it comes to the shapes, sizes, and configurations, you’ll be spoilt for choice. Typically made from steel or aluminum bars, cargo baskets for cars can be easily attached to a roof rack’s crossbars. 

Thanks to their multi-bar construction, a roof cargo basket can accommodate a wide range of items, from bulky gear like kayaks and bikes to smaller items like luggage and camping supplies. Their open design also makes them more accessible, which means you can load and unload items easily. When not in use, you can remove them, improving efficiency and aerodynamics. 

Cargo Boxes: A Deep-Dive

If you don’t want to draw attention to the gear you’re carrying, roof cargo boxes are the way to go. They also protect your gear from harsh weather conditions such as rain, snow, dust, etc. Cargo boxes are typically equipped with more features than cargo baskets, including hinges, locks, latches, straps, and struts. Since a Thule cargo box has an enclosed design, it is also more theft-proof than cargo baskets, so you need not worry about prying eyes. 

You can choose from a wide variety of materials and construction, depending on your budget. Note that entry-level roof boxes might be pocket-friendly but usually have flimsy attachment methods; you should go for midgrade boxes to get sturdy components and reliable attachment methods. 

Interestingly, cargo boxes are designed more aerodynamically than open baskets which means if you’re driving at highway speeds, these boxes can help minimize wind noise and enhance fuel efficiency. 

Factors to Consider Before Making A Choice

Here is a breakdown of how to choose between cargo baskets and cargo boxes, focusing on the key factors that will influence your decision:

1. What will you be carrying?

• If you plan to frequently transport odd-shaped or oversized items such as bikes, kayaks, camping gear, or extra tires, cargo baskets for cars are highly recommended. Its open design allows enough flexibility to carry things of different shapes and sizes. 

• If you want to carry weather-sensitive items, be it luggage, electronics, clothing, or anything that needs protection from external elements, a cargo box is better as it ensures a sealed, weatherproof environment. 

2. Where will you be traveling?

• A cargo basket is a no-brainer if you live in a dry area with barely any rain or snow. 

• On the other hand, for areas encountering frequent rain, snow, or harsh weather, a cargo box is a must to keep your gear dry and protected. 

• For long road trips, the aerodynamic design of a cargo box is advantageous, as it helps minimize wind resistance and improve fuel efficiency. 

3. How important is security?

• If you are traveling to safe areas and don’t intend to leave your vehicle unattended for long periods, a cargo basket with secure straps has you covered. 

• If you’re concerned about theft, you should opt for a lockable cargo box that provides security for your belongings. 

4. What’s your budget?

• If you have budget constraints, cargo baskets for cars will be a more affordable option for you. 

• If you prioritize weather protection, security, and aerodynamics, don’t think twice before investing in a Thule roof box, though it comes at a higher price.

5. How often will you use it?

• Need extra cargo space for only few times in a year? A less expensive basket might suffice.

• For frequent use, it’s advisable to go for a higher-quality box with better features and durability.

 The following table can make your choice easier:

Conclusion

Still unsure of whether you want to experience the rugged versatility of a cargo basket or settle for the sleek protection of a cargo box?  Make a list of your typical cargo, consider the climates you'll be traveling in, and revisit the pros and cons we've outlined.  Don't forget to measure your vehicle's roof rack and check weight capacities before you buy.  With a little planning, you'll be well on your way to maximizing your cargo space and enjoying stress-free travels. No matter your choice, the extra cargo space will open up a world of possibilities.